Compare Short Haul (<500 km)

Train vs Flight: Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld

Q: Is train or flight faster from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld?

Train is faster door-to-door from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld. The train takes 1h 41m door-to-door (including 1h 11m journey + 30 min station check-in), while flying takes 2h 35m (including 5m flight + 2.5 hours at the airport).

Q: How much CO2 does the Birmensdorf ZH-Erstfeld train vs flight produce?

For the Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld route (62 km straight-line), the train produces approximately 2,5 kg of CO2 per passenger, while the flight produces approximately 15,8 kg. Taking the train saves 13,3 kg of CO2 — a 84% reduction. These are average estimates based on European averages (train: 41g CO2/km, flight: 255g CO2/km incl. radiative forcing).

Q: What is the door-to-door travel time for train vs flight Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld?

Door-to-door travel time from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld: Train takes 1h 41m total (1h 11m journey + 30 min station check-in). Flight takes 2h 35m total (5m flight + 2.5 hours airport overhead for check-in, security, boarding, and taxi).

Q: Is the Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld train worth it vs flying?

For this short-haul route from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld, train is the clear winner. Airport check-in, security, and boarding add over 2.5 hours to your journey. The train departs from the city centre and arrives directly in the heart of Erstfeld, saving 13 kg of CO2 compared to flying.

Q: How far is Birmensdorf ZH from Erstfeld?

The straight-line distance from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld is 62 km (62 km). The actual rail distance will be longer due to track routing.

🇨🇭 Birmensdorf ZH → 🇨🇭 Erstfeld · 62 km

Verdict

Train wins door-to-door on this short route — airport overhead makes flying impractical.

For this short-haul route from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld, train is the clear winner. Airport check-in, security, and boarding add over 2.5 hours to your journey. The train departs from the city centre and arrives directly in the heart of Erstfeld, saving 13 kg of CO2 compared to flying.

Comparison

	Train ✓	Flight
Journey time	1h 11m	5m
Door-to-door incl. check-in / airport	1h 41m +30 min at station	2h 35m +2h 30min at airport
CO2 emissions avg. estimate per passenger	2,5 kg	15,8 kg
Est. ticket price rough estimate only	~€5	~€7
City centre arrival	Central station	Airport (outside city)

* Price and CO2 figures are rough average estimates. Actual values vary by booking class, date, operator, and energy mix. Journey times are based on existing route data or standard speed assumptions.

CO2 Savings

Save 13,3 kg CO2 — 84% less than flying

Train: 2,5 kg CO2 · Flight: 15,8 kg CO2 (41g/km train vs 255g/km flight, European averages incl. radiative forcing)

Train

2,5 kg

Flight

15,8 kg

Door-to-Door Breakdown

Train

Faster door-to-door

Check-in at station 30 min

Journey time 1h 11m

Total door-to-door 1h 41m

Flight

Airport overhead 2h 30 min

Flight time 5m

Total door-to-door 2h 35m

Train tickets for this route

Birmensdorf ZH → Erstfeld · full route details

View route details →

Frequently Asked Questions

Is train or flight faster from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld?

Train is faster door-to-door from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld. The train takes 1h 41m door-to-door (including 1h 11m journey + 30 min station check-in), while flying takes 2h 35m (5m flight + 2h 30min airport overhead).

How much CO2 does the Birmensdorf ZH–Erstfeld train vs flight produce?

For the Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld route (62 km straight-line), the train produces approximately 2,5 kg of CO2 per passenger, while the flight produces approximately 15,8 kg. Taking the train saves 13,3 kg of CO2 — a 84% reduction. These are average estimates based on European averages (train: 41g CO2/km, flight: 255g CO2/km including radiative forcing).

What is the door-to-door travel time for train vs flight Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld?

Door-to-door travel time from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld:

Train: 1h 41m total (1h 11m journey + 30 min station check-in)
Flight: 2h 35m total (5m flight + 2h 30min airport overhead for check-in, security, boarding, and taxi)

Is the Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld train worth it vs flying?

How far is Birmensdorf ZH from Erstfeld?

The straight-line distance from Birmensdorf ZH to Erstfeld is 62 km. The actual rail distance will be longer (typically ~1.3× the straight-line distance) due to track routing.